Repair And Restoration
Houston - We Have A Problem
Diagnosis Date - 4 February 2019
As you are all aware my mobile technician (aka Ren) was pressed into helping with my shims and tappets last week.
With the snow I have not used the bike for work and gone in the car. However on Saturday I used the bike and returned home on a crisp and very cold winter's evening at 7pm. When I arrived in the garage I noticed my right leg had a big round wet patch on it. I felt the stuff which I initially thought was oil. It was quite slippery and appeared to be engine oil. As I had just changed the oil and filter it looked like fresh clean oil does.
I decided to have a look the next day and the right hand side of the bike was a bit oily, I could see drip marks from near the cylinder head gasket. Hmm. I had sprayed ACF50 on the engine so I wiped down the bike and ran the engine. No sign of a leak... The rocker cover looked OK but there did seem to be a slight drip near the round disks that are part of the rocker cover.
Damn and blast...
I rang Ren and obviously he was concerned. He suggested perhaps a fork oil leak or possibly the crankcase cover where we rotated the engine to TDC could be at fault. I had a quick look but family visits forced me to look on the Monday morning. I took off the side cover and the front fairing which both came off pretty easily. I just forgot the little plastic push in fixing. I was quite impressed with myself for getting the bike to this stage, Ren's tuition obviously did the trick. I cleaned everywhere I could and took the bike for a spin. I did 2 miles and stopped at Mottram to have a look. I couldn't see anything leaking or oil blowing out. Very strange.
I drove 3 miles down the motorway and as I pulled off I could see some fluid flying off near my knee. I rode home and saw the problem. Erm - ignore the heavy breathing I was bloody frozen, I had only put a thin scruffy jacket on for the ride. (Idiot, it's bloody winter).
The top radiator clip was fitted and pretty damn tight but fluid was dripping out. I then noticed the clip was about 5-6mm further back from the radiator than it used to be. Bloody difficult to move it's quite a tight fit under there. I moved it along 5mm with a bit of huffing and puffing and shoving with a screwdriver on the side.
Ha that's got it. Peter the mechanic, I'm quite impressed with moving that along. Going to change my middle name to REN.
Right how much fluid have I lost? Quite a bit by the look of it. I wriggle under the rear wheel and clean the expansion tank with some Muc Off spray. Damn I can't see see bugger all. I try and rock the bike, still nothing. It's like a white plastic tub with a min line and a max line but I can't see the fluid, I can't see anything moving. Maybe it hasn't got any coolant left!
I try again. Eventually after putting my heavy bike chain and my helmet in the top box the bike rocks a bit easier and when the torch is just in the right place - voila! You see coolant. God I am getting good at this bike fixing stuff.
Definitely needs fluid now. What did Ren say? It must be a certain one? I rang the dealer who states they have the correct stuff in. I ask if its silicate free and OAT compatible. The silence was sudden and lengthy,
"hmm not sure just a minute. It doesn't say on the bottle, just a minute... It's the one Honda sends us, it's fine no one's had a problem." I explain about the aluminium corrosion problem. "Err this is fine." I point out the manual states it must be the proper one or the warranty will be invalidated.
He responds "no one would ever be able to tell, we use it on all our bikes, we get great big drums of the stuff we have never had a problem. Just a minute I will ask the lads in the workshop." I can hear a brief discussion and the tech says
"look on the barrel it's got a sticker on it."
He reads the sticker which states "Not suitable for Magnesium Alloy Engines." He then states "Your engine's aluminium so its fine! I can get the other stuff but only in big bottles but it will take a few days."
Somewhat bemused I say OK no problem I will think about it.
Hmmmmm. I remember seeing something about this on the internet regarding certain Rover engines with an alloy block. This resulted in the cooling passages blocking due to corrosion and eventually blowing the cylinder head gaskets. This was as a result of poor head gaskets which were being corroded by the incorrect coolant.
Honda blocks are made of 319 Alloy.
319 alloy is 85.8% to 91.5% aluminium, 5.5% to 6.5% silicon, 3% to 4% copper, 0.35% nickel, 0.25% titanium, 0.5% manganese, 1% iron, 1% zinc and 0.1% magnesium
A quick search on the internet reveals the correct coolant - OAT and silicates free at Halfords. I click and collect it online. £12.50 for 2l.
After a trip to Asda and Halfords I return to the garage but I cant find the filler pipe I made from a bit of old hosepipe for Ren's visit. Never mind I cut another bit off the hose pipe. Hopefully Paula wont notice. I put two glugs in remembering Ren hardly put any in when we removed the pipe. I get under the bike and it's much easier to spot the fluid now just under the top line so that's good.
I put on a little more substantial clothing this time and pop off to test it on the same route. I take her up to 80 on the short stretch of motorway. My leg looks dry. After a good look around the bike all appears well.
So what have we learned REN? That Honda bikes are awful to work on lol.
But I'm not looking at the negatives here I'm looking at the positives. My bike is running a treat. I learnt to identify a problem and take the damn thing apart as per Ren's instructions. I've fixed a tiny little problem which could have happened if I had taken it to Honda. Who would have thought that clip could have caused a leak when it wasn't quite in the right place. So really its turned out quite well. Except for the dealer. Hmm I think I will email Honda and checkout what they say, might be interesting if they think the coolant is fine.
The young lady in Halfords said exactly what Ren did. You have to be really careful as the coolants can mix and form a gel like substance. I gently mixed some coolant, my new stuff with some old stuff I had which was the wrong stuff. Nothing happened but when I gently heated it in some foil guess what small blobs of goo appeared in the bottom. it took a while but definitely some gel like stuff appeared. Hmm they might block up your pipes.....
If like Pocketpete you'd like to publish your spanner wielding experiences contact firstname.lastname@example.org
Steve said :-
Pete I thought you had just filled up with Halfords pink stuff, is the new stuff you picked up from Halfords different?
6/2/2019 5:30:46 PM UTC
Pocketpete said :-
That post crossed in the post so to speak. I filled up with the very pink looking halfords stuff prior to when Ren posted this post, post leak so to speak. So my previous fill up was this one mentioned in this post as well as the other post which your wernt aware off because of rens late posting of this article.
God I'm getting confused now...
Suffice it to say I filled my bike with pink coolant from halfords when it needed topping up..
6/2/2019 8:04:00 PM UTC
Shepherd said :-
I gotta post this question ... isn't the stuff leaking out blue?
And you added pink?
Banish my fears Mr.Pocket, as I've been reading this blog thingy ever since getting my first bike way back ... at Christmas 2018!:-)
6/2/2019 10:00:24 PM UTC
Pocketpete said :-
Yes the bike contains an unknown blue coolant which may or may not be the correct coolant. As it came from the factory/dealer like that. I have simply topped up with pink stuff which is supposed to be the correct coolant according to Honda which I got from halfords as I couldn't get the right stuff from the two local Honda dealers.
6/2/2019 11:00:42 PM UTC
Steve said :-
Ah i think i see, when you said you poured in the pink stuff, you meant you topped up. I mistakenly thought you had changed the coolant out to the Halfords OAT. Now that you have found the leak I would be tempted to drain the system and fill up with the OAT coolant from Halfords.
I also had a Yamaha xt660z which I ran for a few years, the service records said coolant change at the 24k. I rang the garage and they said we always use Rock Oil Ice silicate free coolant. I checked the coolant colour and it was green,
I called Rock and they confirmed that the Rock oil ICE silicate free coolant was blue, i drained the coolant and filled up with Halfords OAT pink stuff and ran the bike for another 15k with no problems.
6/2/2019 11:42:07 PM UTC
Ian Soady said :-
You really don't want to mix OAT and non-OAT as they can cause sludge. Not a good thing in the cooling system. See link.
If I was you I'd flush the whole thing out with clean water and refill with the correct concentration of OAT. One problem is that there is no standardisation on colours so you can't rely on pink being OAT and blue being IAT based. And often it's not even stated on the container. Madness.
7/2/2019 10:33:29 AM UTC
Pocketpete said :-
I think your right and I should flush the lot but I'm trusting Honda put the right stuff in when the bike was built. Going to drain the brakes soon and then next year might flush the radiator might be an interesting thing to do. Now Wheres the plug hole....
7/2/2019 3:49:41 PM UTC
Borsuk said :-
I have 2 containers with antifreeze in my workshop at home. Both are ethylene glycol based, both are the same concentration and manufacturer and from the same petrol station, one is pale green the other is blue. The difference, they were bought a couple of months apart. And the new stock was adifferent colour from the old stock. I really hate when you go on a forum and someone says the correct antifreeze is the blue one, or the pink one. Colour means sod all and changes at the manufacturers whim. I think my quad and car both have aluminium engines and both run on the old glycol antifreezes and neither manual mentions silicates.
7/2/2019 4:01:32 PM UTC
Borsuk said :-
Just been re reading this and was thinking, must check and see what the Himalayan uses. Actually had the workshop manual on the screen when I remember it´s oil cooled.
I need to get out more.
12/2/2019 10:57:27 PM UTC
Ren - The Ed¹ said :-
You're not alone Borsuk. I have, on occasion, had a very brief panic while riding the 125. "Oh god! I can't recall ever changing the coolant on the 125!!" Just that short moment of panic until the brain drops back into gear and I remember it's air cooled.
13/2/2019 6:15:11 AM UTC
Borsuk said :-
Good to know that I will have company in my senescence.
13/2/2019 2:02:24 PM UTC
Add a RELEVANT link
Upload an image
Repair And Restoration